Apple Pie Variations & Ice Cream Pairings

A sharp cheddar crust wants a different scoop than a tart cranberry filling. Pick an ice cream for the pie on your counter, or choose a filling, a scoop and a finishing touch for the next one you bake.

Already have an apple pie?

Tart apple filling

Try butter pecan. Butter and toasted nuts soften the bite of a tart apple, and the pecans add crunch to a tender slice.

Sweet crumb topping

Try sour cream ice cream. Its tang gives the brown sugar some contrast. Plain frozen yogurt works here too.

Plenty of cinnamon or clove

Try sweet cream. Its simple milk flavor gives the spice somewhere to land. Vanilla bean is a good second choice.

Eight ways to serve apple pie

Brown butter & sage

Swap the butter you usually dot over the apples for the same amount of browned butter. Let a small sage leaf steep in it as it cools, then lift it out.

The scoop Vanilla bean. Vanilla gives the toasted butter room to come through.

The finish Crisp a few small sage leaves in butter. Perch one on each scoop just before serving.

Cranberry & orange

Replace a small handful of the sliced apples with cranberries. Grate a little orange zest into the filling sugar, stopping before you reach the bitter white pith.

The scoop Sweet cream. A milky scoop softens the sharp cranberry pockets and lets the orange peel carry the aroma.

The finish Rub a pinch of fine orange zest into sugar and scatter a little over the baked crust.

Maple apple & sharp cheddar crust

Use maple sugar in place of some of the filling sugar. Fold a handful of finely grated sharp cheddar into the cold flour and butter for the top crust.

The scoop Toasted walnut. Walnut picks up the savory edge of the cheddar and the toastier notes of maple.

The finish Break a toasted walnut over the spot where the scoop meets the warm slice.

Ginger & cardamom

Grate a little fresh ginger over the apples. Crush the seeds from one green cardamom pod with the filling sugar, then taste a slice of apple before adding more.

The scoop Pistachio. The mellow nut flavor rounds out ginger’s heat and leaves the cardamom fragrant.

The finish Cut crystallized ginger into fine slivers and lay two or three across the scoop.

Classic cinnamon apple

Toss tart and sweet apple slices together with cinnamon sugar. Keep the other spices light so you can taste the difference between the two apples.

The scoop Sour cream. Its gentle tang cuts through the sweet filling, especially if the pie has a crumb topping.

The finish Spoon a thin ribbon of cider caramel around the slice so the crust stays crisp.

Blackberry & lemon zest

Replace a few apple slices with blackberries and rub lemon zest into the sugar. Fold the berries in last to keep pockets of dark fruit intact.

The scoop Lemon custard. The custard echoes the peel in the pie while its richness softens the tart berries.

The finish Split a fresh blackberry and set the halves cut-side up beside the slice.

Toasted oat & pecan crumble

For a crumb-topped pie, replace some of the oats in your usual crumble with roughly chopped pecans. Leave a few larger pieces for crunch.

The scoop Coffee. A little bitterness balances the brown sugar and draws out the toasted pecans.

The finish Save a pinch of toasted oats for the scoop, where they will still crackle at the table.

Pear, apple & vanilla

Replace about a quarter of the apples with firm pear slices. Rub vanilla bean seeds into the sugar and leave the cinnamon out so the pear comes through.

The scoop Dark chocolate. A small scoop gives the mellow fruit a bittersweet edge. Keep it beside the slice so you can alternate bites.

The finish Shave a curl of dark chocolate over the pear filling just before serving.